California drivers know the sting of filling up at the pump, where prices often hover $1.50 to $2 above the national average—$4.65 per gallon versus $3.15 nationally as of April 2025. While crude oil and refining costs play a role, the real culprit behind these sky-high prices is a web of state taxes, fees, and regulations that inflate costs far beyond what’s necessary. Add to that the elevated operational costs for gas stations in California’s pricey real estate and regulatory environment, and it’s clear why motorists are squeezed. Worse, the state’s aggressive climate policies, like cap-and-trade and low carbon fuel standards, promise global environmental gains but deliver negligible impact, raising questions about their prudence.
Let’s break down the numbers. According to the California Energy Commission, taxes and fees account for roughly $1.35 per gallon of gasoline in 2024. The state excise tax, the highest in the nation, stands at 59.6 cents per gallon, up from 27.8 cents in 2017, with annual increases tied to inflation. The federal excise tax adds 18.4 cents, unchanged since 1993. State and local sales taxes, averaging 2.25% but varying by region, contribute about 14.4 cents at current prices. A 2-cent underground storage tank fee funds cleanup of leaking fuel tanks. Then come California’s signature climate programs: the Cap-and-Trade system, which tacks on 27 to 31 cents per gallon by charging fuel suppliers for carbon emissions, and the Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS), currently adding 10 cents per gallon, is projected to increase costs to potentially 47 cents or more per gallon as early as sometime in 2025, pending regulatory approval, with estimates suggesting costs could climb to $1.50 by 2035. All told, these levies mean Californians pay an effective tax rate of 45% on gasoline, doubling the cost of refining and delivery.
Beyond taxes, California’s unique fuel regulations drive up prices. The state mandates a special reformulated gasoline blend to reduce smog, costing about 10 to 15 cents more per gallon to produce than standard blends. This “fuel island” status, coupled with strict refinery rules, limits supply options, spiking prices during disruptions like maintenance shutdowns. A 2019 report from the Center for Jobs pegged these regulatory costs at 19.6% of the price gap with the national average. Meanwhile, the state’s push for summer and winter blends adds another 10 to 15 cents, as refineries retool twice yearly.
Gas stations themselves face steep operational costs in California’s high-rent, high-regulation environment. Real estate prices in urban areas like Los Angeles or San Francisco inflate land and lease costs, while insurance rates—driven by wildfire risks and litigation—far exceed those in states like Texas or Arizona. The Energy Commission estimates distribution and marketing costs, which include these expenses plus station profits, at 51 cents per gallon. With California’s 10,000 gas stations serving twice as many drivers per station as the national average, reduced competition lets retailers pass these costs to consumers. A 2023 UC Berkeley study confirmed that fewer stations mean less price competition, further inflating margins.
The justification for much of this burden is California’s ambition to lead on climate change, aiming for an 85% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2045. But the global impact of these measures is dubious. California produces just 1% of global emissions, and its transportation sector accounts for a fraction of that. The LCFS and Cap-and-Trade programs, while raising fuel costs, displace only a sliver of global fossil fuel use—30 billion gallons since 2011, per state claims, against 1.4 trillion gallons consumed globally in 2023 alone. Even if California eliminated all petroleum demand, China and India’s rising emissions would dwarf the savings. A 2024 Kleinman Center report warns that LCFS costs could hit $1.50 per gallon by 2035 without guaranteed emission reductions, as fuel producers can buy credits to skirt cleaner production.
This regulatory zeal lacks prudence when the economic pain is so acute. For a family driving 240 miles weekly in a 20-mpg car, California’s $1.50 price premium adds $936 annually—money that could cover groceries or childcare. Small businesses, reliant on diesel-fueled trucks, face even steeper hikes, with diesel taxes and fees at $1.24 per gallon. The state’s $28 billion from Cap-and-Trade funds projects like high-speed rail, but only 25% goes to transit, while administrative bloat siphons off gains. Republicans’ calls to pause LCFS expansions or cut taxes have been rebuffed, leaving drivers to bear the cost of symbolic climate gestures.
California’s gas prices reflect a government prioritizing ideological goals over practical relief. With taxes, fees, and regulations piling on, and operational costs squeezing stations, the state’s policies hit hardest at the pump. Until Sacramento rethinks its approach, Californians will keep paying for regulations that cost dearly but change little on the global stage.
—
Jon Fleischman is the Publisher of the FlashReport Website on California Politics. Permission to reprint granted with attribution to this site.