Gerrymandering Necessitates the Initiative Process
Yesterday’s Flash Report highlighted an excellent Golden Pen selection from George Will regarding the judiciary’s meddling in Proposition 8. Among his many keen observations, Will made the following comment about states’ use of the initiative process:
“Passing laws by referenda is an imprudent departure from the core principle of republican government – representation: The people do not decide issues, they decide who shall decide. But the right of Californians to make laws through the direct democracy of referenda is as firmly established as it is promiscuously exercised.”
Although Will doesn’t seem to agree with the initiative process—based on republican principles—he concedes its use has passed constitutional muster. Will’s position recalled to my mind an experience I had last year when I was helping collect signatures for the marriage constitutional amendment. One man I talked to said that although he agreed with the amendment’s definition of marriage, he would not sign the petition because he believed, as George Will argues, the initiative process violates the… Read More