Fairness in Elections
A case now before the United States Supreme Court, Evenwel v. Abbott, is causing considerable upset among Sacramento Democrats. That is because a victory for the plaintiffs will have a significant positive long term effect on California politics, by potentially ending one party rule.
What is Evenwel about? Nothing short of fundamental fairness in elections. It asks whether states should draw their legislative districts primarily to protect the rights of citizens to an equal vote or to protect the “interests” of the undocumented and felons to “access” to state politicians.
In Evenwel, Texas voters challenged the drawing of Texas legislative districts apportioned according to total population rather than according to the number of citizens of voting age, i.e., each district has roughly the same number of people in it, though the districts can have wildly unequal numbers of voters in them. The plaintiffs contend that this inequality means that the votes of some voters are worth less than the votes of other voters, thus violating the principle of “one-person, one-vote.” For example, if there are 100 citizens eligible to vote in District 1 and 50 citizens… Read More