Get free daily email updates

Syndicate this site - RSS

Recent Posts

Blogger Menu

Click here to blog

Jon Fleischman

Brad Benbrook: One Step Closer To The Prop 11 Redistricting Commission

The latest from FR correspondent Bradley Benbrook, who is keeping a close eye on the redistricting process as we move closer to the redrawing of legislative lines…

One Step Closer To The Prop 11 Redistricting Commission
Bradley Benbrook

California’s new redistricting process took another step forward this week with the selection of a three-member “applicant review panel,” comprised of three CPA’s from the Bureau of State Audits (one Republican, one Democrat, and one decline-to-state) who will review a mountain of applications for Proposition 11’s Citizen’s Redistricting Commission.  Next year this panel will publicly interview applicants and ultimately narrow the field to three groups of 20 Republicans, 20 Democrats, and 20 unaffiliated applicants they deem “most qualified” under Proposition 11’s qualification standards. 

State Auditor Elaine Howell stood before a tightly-packed group of about 40 people – nearly all of whom appeared to work in the State Auditor’s office, and nearly half of whom were themselves prospective panelists – and spun a bingo cage filled with ping-pong balls.  Consistent with the regulations recently adopted by her office, Ms. Howell opened a new box of ping-pong balls for each group of prospective panelists.  The roughly 10-minute process lacked a certain lottery feel to it, since the “winners” of this drawing face a year of hard and potentially controversial work, rather than a pile of money.  Indeed, the first two Republican panelists whose balls were picked actually declined the opportunity to serve.

After their selection, the three panelists (and three alternates) posed for pictures and were quickly ushered out of the room without making statements or taking questions.  The BSA issued a press release that offered this information about the panelists:

NASIR AHMADI [Republican] . . . has over 15 years of experience as an independent auditor with the California State Auditor’s Office. . . .  In addition to the numerous independent audits of California’s financial statements, Mr. Ahmadi has also participated on many audits including audits of the State Bar of California, the Department of Health Services, Department of Transportation, as well as conducted investigations of improper activities by state employees. . . . Mr. Ahmadi has a B.S. in Accounting from CSU, San Diego, and is registered with the Republican Party.


KERRI SPANO [Democrat] has been conducting independent investigative audits as an investigative auditor with the California State Auditor’s Office since 2007. In her position, Ms. Spano investigates improper activities by state employees. Prior to joining the office, for six years Ms. Spano conducted investigative audits with the Department of Justice and independent audits for three years with the Department of Finance. She earned a B.S. in Accounting from CSU Sacramento . . . . Ms. Spano is registered with the Democratic Party.


MARY CAMACHO [Decline to State] has been with the California State Auditor’s Office since 2006 and is currently a Senior Auditor Evaluator II. In her role, she has led independent audits of the California financial statements, the State Overtime Costs, the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board, and the Department of Housing and Community Development. Prior to joining the office, Ms. Camacho conducted independent audits of state entities for 10 years at the Department of Finance. Ms. Camacho earned a B.S. in Accounting at CSU Sacramento . . . .  Ms. Camacho is registered as decline-to-state.

Before the drawing, the panelists were screened for “conflicts of interest” under Proposition 11, which means than none of them have, over the past 10 years:

  • Served as an officer, employee, or paid consultant of a party or of the campaign committee of a candidate for federal or state office;
  • Served as an elected or appointed member of a party central committee;
  • Been a registered federal, state, or local lobbyist;
  • Served as paid congressional or legislative staff; or
  • Contributed two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more to any congressional, state, or local candidate in any year.

One more important thing to note:  The review panel will begin accepting applications for the redistricting commission on December 15, 2009, and the application window remains open until February 12, 2010.   Applications are available on the BSA’s new web site — under the tab marked “Application and Selection Process.”

You can reach Mr. Benbrook, via the FR, here.

Care to read comments, or make your own about today’s Daily Commentary?

Just click here to go to the FR Weblog, where this Commentary has its own blog post, and where you can read and make comments.